Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
History of India History of India, indian history, old india, architecture of india, culture of india, festival of india, education india
Indian History Home | Ancient age | Middle Age | Modern Age | Regional History  
   
 

INDIAN GENERAL HISTORY

   
History of India History of India
History of India Government of India
History of India Politics of India
History of India Foreign relations of India
History of India Military of India
History of India States of India
History of India Geography of India
History of India Economy of India
History of India Demographics of India
History of India Culture of India
History of India Education of India
History of India Religion of India
History of India Festival of India
History of India Languages of India
History of India Yoga of India
History of India Ayurveda
   
Timelines of India
   
History of India Timeline of Karnataka
History of India Timeline of Gandhi's life
History of India Chronology of Mogul Kings
History of India Many other Time-lines
   
India's Freedom Struggle
   
History of India 1857-First Indian War
History of India Mahatma Gandhi
History of India Bal Gangadhar Tilak
History of India Rabindranath Tagore
History of India Madame Bhikaji Cama
History of India Sardar Bhagat Singh
History of India Subhas Chandra Bose
History of India Veer Savarkar
History of India Tippu Sultan
   
History of Religions in India
   
History of India Jainism Variety
History of India Buddhism Variety
History of India Hinduism Variety
History of India Sikhism Variety
History of India The Bhakti Movement
   
Art History
   
History of India Erotic Arts of India
History of India Kavi Art
History of India History of the Saree
History of India Timeline of Art in India
   
Kings, Queens and Rulers
   
History of India Akbar the Great
History of India Maratha King Shivaji
History of India Emperor Ashoka
History of India Queen of Jhansi Lakshmibai
   
Contemporary History
   
History of India Operation Bluestar
History of India The Plague of 1994
History of India The Outsourcing Boom
   
   
Home>> Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose

Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose


"Patriot of Patriots", is what Gandhiji described of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

Netaji Subhash Chandra BoseSubhash Chandra Bose was one of the most influential and charismatic leader of pre-Independence India .

His life was full of mystery and adventure and indeed his death has been a major issue and creates controversy from time to time.

Here we will try to look at some of the events of his life and salute this great man, whose contribution to the Indian freedom movement is immense.

Childhood & Early life of Netaji

Netaji Subhash Chandra was born on January 23rd 1897 in Cuttack (in present day Orissa) as the ninth child among fourteen, of Janakinath Bose and Prabhavati devi.

Rai Bahadur Jankinath Bose was a public lawyer by profession. He was a public prosecutor in Cuttak and later became a member of the Bengal Legislative Council.

The family of Subhash Chandra Bose was a large one consisting of eight brothers and six sisters.

At school, he was always serious, reserved and did not take much interest in sports. The sadhus and pilgrims visiting Puri, the famous shrine near his place, fascinated him.

He was an intelligent kid and stood second in the School examination and took admission in Presidency college, Calcutta.

An interesting episode came in this college in 1916. Here he beat an English professor because of his racist attitude towards Indians. As a result he was expelled from the college.

But his father refused to admit him to another college. Over the course of time he got readmitted in the same University in philosophy.

He passed with flying colours and achieved first class Honours in philosophy.

Recognising his son's intellect, his father was determined that Bose should become a high ranking Indian Civil Servicet (ICS). So he sent him to England for further studies.

In 1920, Bose passed the Civil Service open examination and stood fourth overall with the highest marks in English.

But by this time the Jalianwala Baug massacre had taken place which had disturbed him greatly. Even though he passed the ICS, he was not interested in serving the Britishers.

At this time Gandhiji had established himself as a leader of the masses. Like many others Bose was also influenced by Gandhiji. So he went to Gandhiji and offered himself to work for the Indian National Congress. Gandhiji was not able to turn down this humble request and sent him to Calcutta to work under Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Das.

During the period 1921-25 he was mainly involved in the activities around Calcutta and was arrested on numerous occasions.

In Dec 1921, Bose organised a boycott of the celebrations to mark the Prince of Wales's visit to India. This led to his being imprisoned.

Later he was again imprisoned along with Deshbandhu and the two lived together in jail, where Bose served his leader humbly, even cooking his food. From this time Bose considered Deshbandhu as his Guru.

Netaji In Germany During WW II

Initially Bose wanted to go to Russia, but in the end he reached Germany, because the Russians were not very interested in Indian Independence.

Bose was welcome in Germany, although the news of his arrival there was kept a secret for some time for political reasons. The German Foreign Office, which was assigned the primary responsibility of dealing with Bose and taking care of him, had been well informed of the background and political status of the Indian leader through its pre-war Consulate-General at Calcutta and also by its representative in Kabul.

Bose himself, naturally somewhat impatient for getting into action soon after his arrival in Berlin, submitted a memorandum to the German government on 9th April 1941 which outlined a plan for co-operation between the Axis powers and India. Among other things, it called for the setting up of a "Free India Government" in Europe, preferably in Berlin; establishment of a Free India broadcasting station calling upon the Indian people to assert their independence and rise up in revolt against the British authorities; underground work in Afghanistan involving independent tribal territories lying between Afghanistan and India and within India itself for fostering and aiding the revolution; provision of finances by Germany in the form of a loan to the Free India government-in-exile; and deployment of German military contingents to smash the British army in India.

In a supplementary memorandum bearing the same date, Bose requested that an early pronouncement be made regarding the freedom of India and the Arab countries.

It is significant to note that the memorandum did not mention the need for formation of an Indian legion. Evidently the idea of recruiting the Indian prisoners of war for the purpose of establishing a nucleus of an Indian national army did not occur to him during his early days in Berlin.

At that time the German government was in the process of formulating its own plan for dealing with Subhash Chandra Bose in the best possible manner. The Foreign Office felt itself inadequate to discharge this awesome responsibility without referring the whole matter to Hitler. While this issue was being considered at the highest level of the government, Bose's own requests made it far too complicated and involved to be resolved at an early date.

There was a long wait for Bose, during which period he often tended to become frustrated. Nevertheless, through several sympathetic officers of the Foreign Office, he continued to press his requests and put forth new ideas.

Finally, after months of waiting and many moments of disappointment often bordering on despair for Bose, Germany agreed to give him unconditional and all-out help.

The two immediate results of this decision were the establishment of a Free India Center and inauguration of a Free India Radio, both beginning their operations in November 1941. These two organisations played vital and significant roles in projecting Bose's increasing activities in Germany. The German government put at Bose's disposal adequate funds to run these two organizations, and he was allowed complete freedom to run them the way he liked at his own discretion.

In its first official meeting on 2 November 1941, the Free India Center adopted some historical resolutions that would serve as guidelines for the entire movement in subsequent months and years in Europe and Asia.
First, Jai Hind or Victory to India, would be the official form of salutation; secondly, Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore's famous patriotic song "Jana Gana Mana" was to be the national anthem for the free India Bose was fighting for; thirdly, in a multilingual state like India, the most widely-spoken language, Hindustani, was to be the national language.

During this period both the BBC and Writer, acting like the mouthpieces of the British government, declared that Netaji had died.

In November 1941, Azad Hind Radio (or the Free India Radio) opened its program with an announcing speech by Netaji himself, which, in fact, was a disclosure of his identity that had been kept officially secret for so long. He said " I am Subhash Chandra Bose who is still alive and talking to you". During this broadcast he called Gandhiji as the father of the nation. This message sent shockwave through the British because they did not want to loose India at that crucial stage of the war.

During this time he was given the immortal title of Netaji, the Indian equivalent of the English "leader" or the German "Führer."

Netaji with Japan during WW II

On 15 February 1942, Singapore fell to the Japanese army advancing southward from the Malayan peninsula. Two days later, in an impressive ceremony held at Farrar Park in the heart of the town, [British] Indian troops were handed over to the Japanese as prisoners-of-war by their commanding officer, Colonel Hunt.

Major Fujiwara took them over on behalf of the victorious Japanese, and then announced that he was handing them over to Captain Mohan Singh of the Indian contingents, who should be obeyed by them as their Supreme Commander. Mohan Singh then spoke to the Indian POWs, expressing his intention of raising an Indian national army out of them to fight for India's freedom. He held a preliminary discussion with some prominent Indians in Malay and Burma in a meeting in Singapore on 9 and 10 March, which was attended by Rashbihari Bose, a veteran Indian revolutionary exile living in Japan for the last quarter of a century.

Bose then called a conference in Tokyo, which was held 28-30 March. The delegates representing several East and Southeast Asian countries present at the conference decided to form the Indian Independence League to organize an Indian independence movement in East Asia. Bose was recognized as head of the organization.

The conference further resolved that "military action against the British in India will be taken only by the INA and under Indian command, together with such military, naval and air cooperation and assistance as may be requested from the Japanese by the Council of Action" and further, "after the liberation of India, the framing of the future constitution of India will be left entirely to the representatives of the people of India."

On 15 June 1942, a conference opened in Bangkok with over a hundred delegates of the IIL [Indian Independence League] attending from all over Asia. By the close of the nine-day conference a resolution was unanimously adopted setting forth the policies of the independence movement in East Asia.

The IIL was proclaimed the organization to work for India's freedom; the Indian National Army was declared the military arm of the movement with Mohan Singh as the Commander-in-chief and Rashbehari Bose was elected president of the Council of Action. It was further decided that Singapore would be the headquarters of the IIL.

NetajiNetaji had stated in a message to the conference that his personal experience had convinced him that Japan, Italy and Germany were sworn enemies of British imperialism; yet, independence could come only through the efforts of Indians themselves. India's freedom would mean the rout of British imperialism. The Indian National Army was officially inaugurated in September 1942.

Unfortunately, at this point distrust began to grow within the Indian group against Rasbihari Bose's leadership. Some thought that having been long associated with Japan, he gave precedence to the Japanese interests over Indian interests. According to Japanese records:

Some even thought that he was just the protégé of the Japanese, and that the latter were exploiting Indians for their own ends. Such resentment finally resulted in a revolt of a group of leaders headed by Captain Mohan Singh within the INA in November 1942. As a consequence, Mohan Singh and his associate, Colonel Gill, were both arrested by the Japanese and the Indian Army was disbanded. However, in 1943 a new Indian Army was organized, put under the command of Lt. Col. Bhonsle, who held this post until the final dissolution of the army.

Describing the revived INA. Joyce Lebra writes:

On 15 February 1943, the INA was reorganized and former ranks and badges revived. The Director of the Military Bureau, Lieutenant-Colonel Bhonsle, was clearly placed under the authority of the IIL to avoid any repetition of IIL-ANA rivalry. Under Bhonsle was Lt. Col. Shah Nawaz Khan as Chief of General Staff, Major P.K. Sahgal as Military Secretary; Major Habibur Rahman as commandant of the Officers' Training School; and Lt. Col. A.C. Chatterji, and later Major A.D. Jahangir, as head of enlightenment and culture. Apart from this policy-forming body was the Army itself, under the command of Lt. Col. M.Z. Kiani. This was the organization which held the INA together until the arrival of Subhash Chandra Bose from Berlin, six months later.

In February, the Japanese military officer Iwakuro had called a meeting of about three hundred officers of the INA at Bidadri camp in Singapore and spoke to them about the advisability of joining the army, but with no effect. According to Ghosh, "Later on, in a 'heart-to-heart talk' with some officers, it emerged that a large number of officers and men would be willing to continue in the INA on the express condition that Netaji would be coming to Singapore."

Netaji & Gandhiji


After the death of great leaders like Lokmanya Tilak and Dr. Annie Beasant and martyrdom of revolutionaries like Shaheed Bhagat Singh there were only two major thoughts which were prevalent in India, one was that of Gandhiji and the other was that of Netaji.

While Gandhiji advocated non-violence and talks with the British, Netaji was of the opinion that there should be no compromise with the British and that every means should be used to free India.

In spite of that Gandhiji and Netaji were extremely fond of each other.Netaji started his political life by going to Gandhiji, who directed him to work under Deshbandhu Chittaranjan Das.

He resigned from the post of the INC president only because of the opposition of Gandhiji.


history_spacer

He called Gandhiji as the "Father of the Nation" from Radio Berlin, the much revered title given to Gandhiji.

The great war cry of 'Jai Hind' was given to the nation by Netaji.

Subhas Chandra Bose with Gandhi'Do or Die' used by Gandhiji during the Quit India Movement of 1942, was given by Netaji.

Before leaving the country in 1939( before he was arrested) Netaji met Gandhiji and requested him to start a nation wide mass movement. But Gandhiji refused, since he believed it would cause large scale violence.

When some of his friends told him to do that himself, he said 'If I give a call than 20 lakh people would come, but if Gandhiji gives a call than 20 crore would come.

He also reportedly said that 'it will be tragic for me if I succeeded in winning the confidence of other people but failed to win the confidence of India's greatest man (Mahatma Gandhi)."

After that Netaji and Gandhiji never met with each other.

Netaji first went to Germany and then, in one of the most daring thing, he went to Japan in a submarine.

In the eventful years of World War II, when Gandhiji gave a call of ''Do or Die'' and Netaji led the Indian National Army to make a fierce assault on the eastern front, the British media tried to magnify the differences between the two great men over the ''non-violent'' and ''violent'' means adopted by them. Gandhiji, while out rightly rejecting the suggestion that he was sympathetic to the Japanese, chided the British media for its blatant hypocrisy.

The atomic bombs were dropped on Japan and on 15th August, 1945 Japan surrendered.

After that Netaji went to an unknown place or died in a plane crash as said by some sources.

It is believed by many that Netaji died in a plane crash ( The webmaster does not subscribe to those views).

According to them his plane stopped at Formosa.

After lunch and refueling, his plane resumed the journey, but within minutes it met with disaster, dived headlong and burst into flames. Bose was picked up badly burnt and bruised. He was removed to the hospital but by 8 or 9 p.m. his end had come.

Many of the close associates of Netaji like Habib ur Rahman said that Netaji dies in a plane crash.

Gandhiji never believed that Netaji could have died, the works of Mahatma Gandhi reveal this.

In his ''heart of hearts'' maintaining that he was not killed, Gandhiji ''intuitively'' believed that Netaji was still hiding in some unknown place and would reappear at an appropriate time to serve his motherland.

Gandhiji had wondered in 1945 how Netaji could die when Swaraj was yet to be achieved. This conviction of Mahatma caused much embarrassment to the British government and even some close comrades of Netaji tried to convince him that Netaji was really killed in the plane crash.

Despite the sharp differences over the means to be used for achieving independence for the country, Gandhiji always adored Netaji for his extraordinary valour and organising capacity, the memoirs reveal.

Gandhiji wrote in the issue Harijan of (24-2-1946) that ''Subhash Chandra Bose's patriotism is second to none.''

The Bombay Chronicle then wrote that Gandhiji still believes in his heart of hearts that Netaji is alive.

Gandhiji dealt the issue of Netaji's reported death in Harijan under the title, 'Is Netaji Alive?'.

He wrote, ''Some time back it was announced in the newspapers that Subhash Chandra Bose had died. I believed the report. Later the news was proved to be incorrect. Since then I have had a feeling that Netaji could not leave us until his dream of swaraj had been fulfilled. To lend strength to this feeling was the knowledge of Netaji's great ability to hoodwink his enemies and even the world for the sake of his cherished goal.''

But when close associates of Netaji like Captain Habibur Rahman narrated the last moments of Netaji after the plane crash, Gandhiji reconciled to the fact that Netaji had left the countrymen. He, at the same time stressed that, ''He is living with us in his message and the ideals he placed before the world.''

When one of the soldiers of 'INA' asked Gandhiji in 1948, what would he have done if Netaji had returned to him victorious, Gandhiji replied, ''I would have asked him to put away the weapons and stack them before me.''

Interestingly this was the very instruction Netaji gave to the fighting 'INA' men. Captain Shah Nawaz Khan told Gandhiji that Netaji had asked 'INA' soldiers that in an independent India, they would be expected to serve their country not by means of swords but through non-violence.

The last words of Netaji (according to his close associate Habib-ur Rehman) were: ''I don't think I will recover. So when you go back to India, do tell our countrymen that I tried my best to wrest freedom but they should continue their struggle until they succeed.''

Before he died however, he dictated this message to his companion: "I have fought for Indian freedom till the last. Tell my countrymen India will be free before long. Long live free India!"

Netaji often used to declare that if and when he succeeded in freeing India from British rule, he would immediately relinquish mundane pursuits leaving his countrymen to manage their own affairs.

Did Netaji really die?

Did Netaji really die at Formosa? This is a question which has been asked umpteen number of times with no satisfactory answer available. This has also been debated time and again by both Netaji loyalists as well as the media and the people of India at large.

Here we will try to explore this mystery, but by no means it is the definitive article on his death.

After dropping of the atom bomb in Hiroshima on August 8, 1945 and Nagasaki on August 9, the Japanese surrendered. But Netaji was not willing to do that since he was fighting to free India from the British.

According to Gordon, Bose flew to Bangkok on August 16, 1945 and to Saigon on August 17. He was accompanied by Col. Habibur Rehman, Col. Pritam Singh, Major Abid Hasan, S.A. Ayer and Debnath Dass. Bose had hoped to take all of them, but in vain. In Saigon, the plans had to be changed. Bose was told that only one place was available in the aircraft which was to leave for Taipei and then Dairen (Manchuria). One more seat was secured for him.

Among his Japanese co-passengers accompanying Bose in the aircraft was the Lieutenant-general Shidei, a Japanese expert on the Soviet Union who was to fly to Dairen to take command of the Kumantang army to work out the surrender. In a bomber of the 97-2 (sally type), Netaji and Col. Habibur Rehman boarded the aircraft with two heavy suit cases filled with gold and jewellery. There were ten other Japanese in the plane which took off from Tourane on August 18, 1945 between 5 and 5.15 a.m. and flew to Taipei (Japanese Taihoku).

The aircraft again took off from Taipei and just after rising to the height of 30 feet, it burst into flames and crashed. This was on August 18, at about 5 p.m. Bose received extensive burns over his whole body, the more serious ones on the head, chest and thighs. He was in a state of semi-consciousness. In a truck, he was driven up to the hospital. Dr Yoshimi Tameyoshi who attended on Netaji state, "When he (Netaji) was laid on the bed, I personally cleaned his injuries with oil and dressed them. During the first four hours, he was unconscious". Later, when he gained consciousness the doctor asked him 'Whether there was any statement, will or such matter he wanted to make' Bose answered, 'Nothing'. Dr Tameyoshi added,' After the fourth hour he appeared to be sinking into unconsciousness.' At about 23.20 hours, Subhash Chandra Bose died. Apart from the injuries received about there were abrasions on his elbows and knees."

Dr Yoshimi Tameyoshi's statement is a first-class eye-witness account to establish Subhash Chandra Bose's death on August 18, at Takhoku. This statement was brought to light by the noted archivist and historian Dr T.R. Sareen from the achieves of Public Records Office records. Dr Gordon, by using this source, has established Bose's death. We have to note that this statement forms a part of British records submitted to Captain A.R. Turner in-charges of War Crimes Liaison Branch (Formosa).

But the major question arises is whether the statement given by Taneyoshi's is factual or not. Remember that the Britishers were the victor's, and history is written by the winners. Also he could have been pressurised by the Britishers to give such a statement so that a major headache, at least for the time being, could be avoided.

But things are not as simple as said above. There are many big questions which have been left unanswered.

These include - Whether Netaji was really there in the plane at the time of the crash? Was he mortally injured after the crash? Did he somehow escape before or after the crash? Are the ashes at Renkoji temple really his? Was Goomnami Baba really Netaji? Was the crash done by the British intelligence? Was he really captured by the Russians and kept in captivity? If Netaji survived than where did he really went after that and why didn't he made himself public? Where did he disappear?

The first enquiry was setup almost immediately by Lord Wavell, the Viceroy, to look into the disappearance of Netaji. It is believed that after an extensive inquiry they came to the conclusion that Netaji had died. Though no official report have ever been made in this regard.

The first Indian enquiry relating to Netaji's death was commissioned by the Government of India(GOI) under Shah Nawaz Khan, a Railway Minister in the Union Government. He quickly declared that Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose had died at Formosa on the 18th of August, 1945. This decision seemed to be given with a lot of haste and without the necessary investigation. While it is undoubted that he was a great soldier, one of the three most important INA figures after Netaji, but did he really had the skills to carry out an investigation of this nature?

Then came the Khosla enquiry. It was commissioned by the GOI under Prime minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi. It was a one member commission chaired by G.D. Khosla, a retired Chief Justice of the Punjab High Court. It visited many important places like Singapore, Bangkok and Rangoon and interviewed many people.

It is said that the relationship between Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and Khosla were not great. Both of them met in England, when Netaji was giving the ICS examination. It is said that Netaji and Mr. Khosla had a small fight when Netaji returned to India, but Khosla was still keen on giving the exam.

There was a further loss of credibility, because Khosla was said to be very close to the Nehru family and it is historic that in the later years, Netaji and Pandit Nehru were not on the best of terms.

Also Khosla didn't visit many key places like Formosa, which caused a further dent in his credibility.

After four years he gave the verdict that Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose had died at Formosa. For this he relied on the medical report of Dr Yoshimi Taneyoshi, Captain of the Imperial Japanese army, the surgeon in-charge when Netaji was reported to have succumbed.

But this report was rejected by many eminent persons outside the Congress, including Morarji Desai.

The BJP(Bhartiya Janta Party) led NDA(National Democratic Alliance) has instituted the latest such inquiry by setting up Justice J.C. Mukherjee commission.

But a significant amount of time has passed since the incident and most of the documents relating to the period, include those of crashes in Formosa, are not available. Also many key witnesses or those believed to have information in that regard are no longer alive, which will hamper the commission.

But at the same time technology has improved dramatically over the years. DNA testing can be (and have been) done. After the Mukherjee commission's report is made public it may be possible to authoritatively say whether the Renkoji ashes or Goomnami Baba have anything to do with Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.

The report is expected soon (unless there is another extension!) and let's hope that it will have the final word in this controversy.